Choosing how to get your Medicare coverage comes down to one big fork: Original Medicare paired with a Medigap supplement and a Part D drug plan, or an all-in-one Medicare Advantage plan. This advisor turns what matters to you — keeping your doctors, predictable out-of-pocket costs, the lowest monthly premium, coverage while traveling, or bundled dental, vision, and hearing extras — into a ranked shortlist of paths, each with plain-English tradeoffs. It compares real options like Plan G, high-deductible Plan G, Plan N, Advantage HMO and PPO plans, Original Medicare alone, and staying on employer coverage past 65, so you can see which genuinely fits your situation instead of guessing.
The second thing it does is mind the enrollment windows, because in Medicare timing is a gate. Medigap is guaranteed-issue only during your initial window — usually your first six months on Part B — and after that most states let insurers use medical underwriting, which can change what's realistically open to you. So the ranking carries a second axis, Access, alongside fit. This is educational, not insurance advice: plans and prices vary by county and rules vary by state, so confirm the specifics on Medicare.gov's Plan Finder or with your free State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) counselor before you enroll.
What you can do
- Ranks Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage paths
- Flags your enrollment window and access
- Weighs doctors, travel, budget, and extras
- Plain-English tradeoffs for each path
- Points you to Medicare.gov and free SHIP help
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between Medigap and Medicare Advantage?
Original Medicare plus a Medigap supplement lets you see any doctor that accepts Medicare with no networks or referrals, and the supplement covers most cost-sharing for a monthly premium; Medicare Advantage is an all-in-one private plan that usually bundles drug coverage and extras at a lower premium but works within a network. This tool ranks both approaches for your situation, but it's educational only — verify current plan details on Medicare.gov.
Which Medicare path is right for me?
It depends on how much you value keeping specific doctors, predictable costs, low premiums, travel coverage, and extras — and where you stand with enrollment. The advisor weighs those against each path and returns a ranked shortlist with tradeoffs, but availability and prices vary by county and year, so treat it as a starting point and confirm specifics on Medicare.gov or with a free SHIP counselor.
Why does the enrollment window matter?
Medigap is guaranteed-issue only during your initial window — typically your first six months on Part B — meaning insurers must take you regardless of health. After that, most states allow medical underwriting, which can affect whether you can get a supplement later. The tool flags where you stand, but state rules vary, so confirm your exact rights on Medicare.gov or with a SHIP counselor.
How much does each Medicare path cost?
Every path shares the Part B premium as a baseline, and higher incomes pay IRMAA surcharges. Beyond that, Medigap plans carry a real monthly premium in exchange for near-zero surprise bills, while many Advantage plans have a low or zero premium but larger out-of-pocket exposure in a bad year. Actual premiums and out-of-pocket caps vary by county and change each year, so look up current figures on Medicare.gov's Plan Finder rather than relying on any single estimate.
What if I'm still working past 65?
If you have qualifying employer group coverage — generally at a company with 20 or more employees — staying on it and delaying Part B is often the standard move, since it avoids double premiums and preserves a fresh guaranteed-issue Medigap window for when you retire. The advisor accounts for this, but the employer-size rule and drug-coverage "creditable" status matter, so confirm details with your HR department and a free SHIP counselor.
Ready for your recommendation?
The Medicare Path Advisor: Medigap vs. Advantage runs entirely in your browser. Free, no sign-up required to use it.
Related calculators
Other tools that pair well with the Medicare Path Advisor: Medigap vs. Advantage. They cross suites because life does.