Skip to main content
planin30

Learn the history behind the numbers

Retirement income, explained

Saving for retirement has one question; spending in it has another: how much can you take each year without running out? Here is every 30-year retirement since 1928 tested against what markets and prices really did, why the first few years matter most, and the rules on how much must come out of a traditional account.

Plain words first, the method folded underneath, and a source under every number. Our Retirement Planner tests your own withdrawals against a thousand possible markets. Last reviewed November 2026.

A couple in their fifties at the kitchen counter, reading something together on a tablet

At a glance

US figures. Tap one for the history behind it.

How retirement income works

Most retirees live on Social Security, any pension, and what they draw from savings. The first two arrive each month for life; savings have to be spread out. Draw too fast and the money runs out; too slowly and you live on less than you could have. The usual way to think about it is a withdrawal rate: the share of savings you take in the first year, then the same amount raised with prices each year after. At 4%, savings of $1,000,000 pay $40,000 the first year, then that amount raised with prices each year, whether markets rise or fall.

In 1994 a financial planner, William Bengen, took every retirement since 1926, had each take a fixed share of savings in the first year and raise it with prices, and asked which share lasted 30 years every time. The answer was about 4%, and it became the 4% rule. Run again here from 1928 (where our yearly data starts) with US stocks, 10-year Treasury bonds and prices through 2025, 4% with half in stocks lasted in 64 of 69 start years. The exceptions all retired in the mid-to-late 1960s, just before a decade of high inflation and falling markets. The highest rate that lasted every time was 3.6% with half in stocks and 3.8% with three quarters. At 5% it lasted in only 46. Just over half the start years (37 of 69) ended with more than they began with, after prices.

Every 30-year retirement since 1928: did the money last?

Taking 4% a year, 50% in stocks, the money lasted in 64 of 69 start years. The worst start, 1966, ran out in year 25.

Share in stocks (the rest in bonds)

Lasted 30 years

64 of 69

start years, 1928 to 1996

Worst year to retire

1966

ran out in year 25

Typical amount left after 30 years

107%

of what they started with, after prices

lasted 30 years ran out soonerEach bar is someone who retired in that year. They take the first year’s amount at the start of each year, raised with prices, from US stocks (the S&P 500 with dividends) and 10-year Treasury bonds, rebalanced each January, before tax and fees.

Why 4% and not the average return

Half stocks and half bonds grew 4.6% a year after prices, compounded, from 1928 to 2025. Yet taking even 4.5%, less than that, ran out in 12 of 69 start years. A rate that works on average fails whenever the bad years come first, and a retiree only gets one run. Bengen’s 4% was the rate that survived the worst runs in his data; in this run the figure is 3.6%.

Sources: William Bengen, “Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data,” Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994 (opens in a new tab); Damodaran (NYU Stern): historical returns on stocks, bonds and bills, 1928–2025 (January 2026 update) (opens in a new tab); BLS consumer price index, all urban consumers, not seasonally adjusted (FRED CPIAUCNS), December to December (opens in a new tab).

Try it with your own numbers

The Retirement Planner takes your savings, Social Security and spending, then shows how often the money lasts across a thousand possible markets, what a bad run would do, and what retiring a year later or spending a little less would change.

Educational information, not individual financial, investment or tax advice. History is a guide to the range of outcomes, not a forecast.