Learn the history behind the numbers
Retirement income, explained
Saving for retirement has one question; spending in it has another: how much can you take each year without running out? Here is every 30-year retirement since 1928 tested against what markets and prices really did, why the first few years matter most, and the rules on how much must come out of a traditional account.
Plain words first, the method folded underneath, and a source under every number. Our Retirement Planner tests your own withdrawals against a thousand possible markets. Last reviewed November 2026.

At a glance
US figures. Tap one for the history behind it.
- 4% a year, half in stocks, lasted 30 yearsretirements starting 1928 to 1996; the worst, 1966, ran out in year 2564 of 69
- Morningstar’s safe starting rate for 2026the 4% rule’s author now says 4.7%3.9%
- Growth after prices in the first ten years for someone who retired in 19663.8% a year over all 30, yet 4% ran out-1.7% a year
- Must come out of a traditional IRA at 75 (born 1960 or later)6.3% at 85; at 73 for anyone born 1951 to 19594.1%
- Starting withdrawal rate in our Retirement Plannerwith the money planned to last to 954%
How retirement income works
Most retirees live on Social Security, any pension, and what they draw from savings. The first two arrive each month for life; savings have to be spread out. Draw too fast and the money runs out; too slowly and you live on less than you could have. The usual way to think about it is a withdrawal rate: the share of savings you take in the first year, then the same amount raised with prices each year after. At 4%, savings of $1,000,000 pay $40,000 the first year, then that amount raised with prices each year, whether markets rise or fall.
In 1994 a financial planner, William Bengen, took every retirement since 1926, had each take a fixed share of savings in the first year and raise it with prices, and asked which share lasted 30 years every time. The answer was about 4%, and it became the 4% rule. Run again here from 1928 (where our yearly data starts) with US stocks, 10-year Treasury bonds and prices through 2025, 4% with half in stocks lasted in 64 of 69 start years. The exceptions all retired in the mid-to-late 1960s, just before a decade of high inflation and falling markets. The highest rate that lasted every time was 3.6% with half in stocks and 3.8% with three quarters. At 5% it lasted in only 46. Just over half the start years (37 of 69) ended with more than they began with, after prices.
Every 30-year retirement since 1928: did the money last?
Taking 4% a year, 50% in stocks, the money lasted in 64 of 69 start years. The worst start, 1966, ran out in year 25.
Lasted 30 years
64 of 69
start years, 1928 to 1996
Worst year to retire
1966
ran out in year 25
Typical amount left after 30 years
107%
of what they started with, after prices
Why 4% and not the average return
Half stocks and half bonds grew 4.6% a year after prices, compounded, from 1928 to 2025. Yet taking even 4.5%, less than that, ran out in 12 of 69 start years. A rate that works on average fails whenever the bad years come first, and a retiree only gets one run. Bengen’s 4% was the rate that survived the worst runs in his data; in this run the figure is 3.6%.
- 69 overlapping 30-year windows, starting 1928 to 1996. Yearly returns: the S&P 500 with dividends and the 10-year Treasury (Damodaran, NYU Stern), rebalanced to the mix each January. Prices: the consumer price index, December to December.
- The withdrawal comes out at the start of each year, and everything is worked in starting-year dollars, so the withdrawal stays the same number and each return is after that year’s inflation. No taxes, no fees.
- Bengen tested start years 1926 to 1976 with 50% to 75% in stocks; our yearly returns begin in 1928. For a 40-year retirement (start years 1928 to 1986) the rate that lasted every time falls to 3.3% with half in stocks and 3.5% with three quarters.
- Bengen used intermediate-term government bonds and found a little over 4% safe. The 10-year Treasury fell further when interest rates rose in the late 1960s and 1970s, which is why this run finds a little less. The overlapping windows share most of their years, so 69 start years are far fewer independent tests than they look.
Sources: William Bengen, “Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data,” Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994 (opens in a new tab); Damodaran (NYU Stern): historical returns on stocks, bonds and bills, 1928–2025 (January 2026 update) (opens in a new tab); BLS consumer price index, all urban consumers, not seasonally adjusted (FRED CPIAUCNS), December to December (opens in a new tab).
Two people who earn the same growth over 30 years can end up in very different places. Even with no growth at all, 4% lasts 25 years; the 1966 retiree ran out in year 25, no later, because their losses came first. Withdrawals during a fall sell investments when they are cheap, and those shares are not there for the recovery. Someone who retired in 1966 lost ground for a decade as prices rose faster than markets, and by the time returns improved their savings were too small to catch up. Someone who retired in 1982 started with a long boom and ended with about 5 times what they began with, after prices. Economists call this sequence risk; the first five to ten years decide most retirements.
Retiring in 1966 against 1982, both taking 4%, half in stocks
Over 30 years the 1966 retiree's mix grew 3.8% a year after prices. Earned steadily, that would have paid about 5.4% a year for 30 years, yet 4% ran out in year 25, because the first ten years shrank 1.7% a year after prices.
What retirees do about it
Keep a year or two of spending in cash or short bonds so a fall doesn’t force selling stocks. Be ready to trim spending in a bad year: in this history, skipping the inflation raise after each losing year turned all 5 failed start years at 4% into ones that lasted 30 years. Delaying Social Security, which rises with prices for life, means less has to come from savings at all.
In the calculator: the Retirement Planner runs your plan through a thousand possible markets, good orders and bad, and shows how often the money lasts to 95 and what a bad run would look like. Try it with your numbers.
Sources: Damodaran (NYU Stern): historical returns on stocks, bonds and bills, 1928–2025 (January 2026 update) (opens in a new tab); BLS consumer price index, all urban consumers, not seasonally adjusted (FRED CPIAUCNS), December to December (opens in a new tab).
Money in a traditional IRA, 401(k) or 403(b) mostly went in before tax and has grown untaxed, so the IRS sets a minimum that must come out each year, and be taxed as income, once you reach a set age: 75 for anyone born 1960 or later, 73 for 1951 to 1959. These are required minimum distributions. You can always take more; the rule only stops the money staying untaxed forever. Early on the minimum is below 4%, so most people who live on their savings take more than the minimum anyway; it passes 6% at 85 and 10% at 94.
| Born | First required at age |
|---|---|
| 1950 or earlier | 72 (already taking them; 70½ if born before July 1949) |
| 1951 to 1959 | 73 |
| 1960 or later | 75 |
Required each year from a traditional IRA or 401(k), by age
About 3.8% of the account at 73, 6.3% at 85 and 15.6% at 100.
Why it matters before 75
A large traditional account means large required withdrawals later, on top of Social Security, which can push you into a higher tax bracket and raise Medicare premiums. Moving some money to a Roth in the lower-income years between retiring and your start age (a Roth conversion) can lower the total tax if your bracket now is lower than it will be later; the extra income can also raise Medicare premiums two years on. Missing a distribution costs a 25% penalty on the amount not taken, 10% if fixed within two years, and the IRS can waive it for a reasonable error that is put right.
- Each year’s minimum is the balance on December 31 of the year before divided by the distribution period for your age in the Uniform Lifetime Table (IRS Publication 590-B), in force since 2022.
- Starting ages from SECURE 2.0: 73 for anyone born 1951 to 1959, 75 for 1960 or later. The first distribution can wait until April 1 of the following year, but then two fall in the same tax year.
- Someone still working can delay distributions from their current employer’s plan (not an IRA) unless they own more than 5% of the company. Inherited accounts follow separate rules.
- An owner whose spouse is more than ten years younger and the sole beneficiary uses the Joint Life and Last Survivor table instead, which asks for less each year.
Each December Morningstar works out a safe starting rate from forecasts of the next 30 years rather than history: 3.9% for someone retiring in 2026, with 30% to 50% in stocks and a 9 in 10 chance of lasting 30 years. In 2025 Bengen raised his own figure to 4.7%, by adding smaller companies and foreign stocks to the mix. The Retirement Planner’s percentage mode starts at 4% and plans to age 95, holding 40% in stocks through retirement at a planning return of 5.4% a year before inflation (about 2.4% after). The FIRE calculator starts at 4% and shows 3%, 3.5%, 4%, 4.5% side by side; for a retirement of 40 years or more, history points to about 3.3% to 3.5%.
A safe first-year withdrawal, by who's asking
The published answers for a 30-year retirement run from 3.9% to 4.7%. They differ by the investments assumed and how sure they want to be, not by much.
A rule to start from, not to live by
The rule assumes you never change your spending. Real retirees do: most spend less in their late seventies and eighties, then more on health care. Spending a little more in good years and a little less in bad ones lets most people start higher than 4% safely. Use the rate to see whether savings are roughly enough, then plan the spending year by year.
In the calculator: set a withdrawal rate and the FIRE calculator shows the savings you need (25 times spending at 4%) and when you’d get there; the Retirement Saver shows what to put aside each month to get there. Try it with your numbers.
How long the money has to last: Living longer, explained. The returns and inflation we plan with: our planning assumptions.
Sources: Morningstar: What’s a safe retirement withdrawal rate for 2026? (The State of Retirement Income, December 2025) (opens in a new tab); Advisor Perspectives: Bill Bengen boosts the 4% rule to 4.7% (A Richer Retirement, Wiley, August 2025) (opens in a new tab).
Try it with your own numbers
The Retirement Planner takes your savings, Social Security and spending, then shows how often the money lasts across a thousand possible markets, what a bad run would do, and what retiring a year later or spending a little less would change.
Educational information, not individual financial, investment or tax advice. History is a guide to the range of outcomes, not a forecast.




