Learn the history behind the numbers
Rental property, explained
Most US rentals are owned by ordinary people: individuals own 70.2% of rental properties, most of them a single house. Here is what the national surveys say a rental really earns and costs, how often it sits empty, how rents and prices have moved, and how the tax rules have changed since the 1950s.
Plain words first, the method folded underneath, and a source under every number. The cash-flow tool uses the same starting assumptions as our Investment Property calculator. Last reviewed November 2026.

At a glance
US figures. Tap one for the history behind it.
- Rent the average rented house earns, as a share of its value, 20232.7% a year after running costs, before any mortgage4.8%
- Share of rental homes sitting empty, for rent, 20255% to 10.6% since 1956; the calculator allows 5%7.1%
- Running costs as a share of rent, single-unit rentals, 2023tax, insurance, repairs and the rest, before the mortgage43.8%
- Years over which a rental building is deducted, since 198715 years in 1981, 40 before 197127.5
- Mortgage covered by rent after costs, typical mortgaged rented house, 2023the owner tops up the rest, betting on the house gaining value80%
Where a rental’s return comes from
A rental pays its owner in three ways. Rent, after the running costs and the mortgage, is the cash you see each month. Each mortgage payment also pays down the loan, so you own a little more of the house. And the house may rise in value, which you collect only when you sell. Tax shapes all three: depreciation lowers the tax on rent, and some of it is taxed back on sale. Most of the return on a rented house bought with a mortgage today comes from the last two, not the first.
The Census Bureau’s survey of rental owners found the average rented single-unit home worth $413,000 in 2023, renting for $1,651 a month. That is 4.8% of its value a year, and 2.7% once running costs are paid, before any mortgage. That 2.7% is well under a 7% mortgage rate, which is why a rental bought mostly with borrowed money rarely pays its way from rent alone. Rent has risen about as fast as incomes since 1987, noticeably faster than prices in general. Home prices rose faster still, which is good for owners selling and harder on buyers counting on rent.
Rent, home prices and incomes, 1987 to 2025
Since 1987 rent has grown 3.53×, about as fast as household income (3.36×) and faster than prices in general (2.83×). Home prices grew 4.96×.
Home prices for each dollar of rent, 1987 to 2025
A dollar of yearly rent cost 51% more house in 2006 than in 1987, about the same as in 1987 by 2012, and 41% more in 2025. The higher it is, the less rent a purchase earns.
Why the price you pay sets the rent you earn
The same rent on a dearer house is a smaller return. Prices for each dollar of rent peaked in 2006, fell back to 1987’s level by 2012, and in 2025 stood 41% above it. Owners who bought years ago earn far more on what they paid: the survey’s average owner paid $180,000, so the same rent is 6.2% a year on their cost.
- Yields use the 2024 Rental Housing Finance Survey’s means for single-unit properties (money figures for 2023): rent of $1,651 a month, operating costs of $8,670 a year and current value of $413,000. Means of different items across the same properties; a property-by-property median would differ.
- The rent index measures what all tenants pay, including long leases, so it lags asking rents for new leases. Before 1985 it understated rent growth by about 1.4 points a year, which is why the chart starts in 1987.
- Income is the Census median household’s, which has survey changes in 2013 and 2017; fine for a multiple over decades, not for year-to-year moves. The 2025 consumer prices average eleven months, since October 2025 was never published.
Sources: Census Bureau and HUD, 2024 Rental Housing Finance Survey: single-unit rentals (infographic) (opens in a new tab); Bureau of Labor Statistics: consumer price index, rent of primary residence (FRED CUUR0000SEHA) (opens in a new tab); S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index (FRED CSUSHPINSA) (opens in a new tab); Census Bureau: median household income (FRED MEHOINUSA646N) (opens in a new tab); Bureau of Labor Statistics: consumer price index, all items (FRED CPIAUCNS) (opens in a new tab); Crone, Nakamura and Voith, “Rents Have Been Rising, Not Falling, in the Postwar Period” (Philadelphia Fed, 2008) (opens in a new tab); Congressional Research Service, R47332: ownership of US rental housing by investor type (2021 survey) (opens in a new tab).
Every rental sits empty sometimes: between tenants, during repairs, while it’s advertised. The Census Bureau has counted the share of rental homes empty and for rent since 1956. It was lowest in the late 1970s, climbed through the 1990s and peaked in 2009, after the housing crash put many houses up for rent. A 5% allowance means about two and a half weeks without rent a year.
Share of rental homes sitting empty, for rent, 1956 to 2025
Between 5% (1978) and 10.6% (2009); 7.1% in 2025. Rented houses, as opposed to apartments, ran lower: 6% in 2025. The calculator allows 5%.
Allow for empty weeks and unpaid rent
The survey counts empty homes, not rent that tenants owe and never pay, or a month’s rent given away to fill a unit. A house that turns over every year loses more than one with a long-term tenant. 5% is a fair start for a house; use more for a place that turns over often or sits in a weak market.
Sources: Census Bureau, Housing Vacancy Survey: rental vacancy rate, quarterly since 1956 (FRED RRVRUSQ156N) (opens in a new tab); Census Bureau, Housing Vacancy Survey, Table 5: vacancy rates by units in the building, 1968 to now (opens in a new tab).
Running costs are everything but the mortgage: property tax, insurance, repairs, utilities the owner pays, management and fees. For a rented house they averaged $8,670 in 2023, about 43.8% of the rent. Improvements, like a roof or a furnace, came to $5,383 more. Property tax varies most by place: 1.79% of a home’s value a year in Illinois, 0.31% in Hawaii, 0.85% nationally.
Rules of thumb against the average rented house, 2023
The average single-unit rental earns 0.4% of its value a month in rent, well short of the 1% rule. Running costs take about 43.8% of rent, under the 50% rule before big repairs, and about 71% once they are added.
The 1% rule Monthly rent of at least 1% of the price
Measured as a share of the value each month.
The 50% rule Half the rent goes to costs, before the mortgage
Measured as a share of the rent.
Upkeep of 1% a year Improvements and big repairs cost 1% of the value a year
Measured as a share of the value each year.
Use the rules to screen, not to decide
Rules of thumb are quick filters. The 1% rule comes from cheaper markets and years; few rentals in most cities pass it now. The 50% rule looks generous until the roof or the furnace goes: counting those, costs took about 71% of rent. A newer house costs less to keep up and an old one more. The calculator lists each cost on its own line, so you can put in real quotes.
- Operating costs are the survey’s mean total operating expenses per unit, excluding mortgage payments. Improvements are its mean capital improvements per unit. Both are averages across owners, with wide margins of error ($5,383 plus or minus $2,773).
- Property-tax rates are taxes paid as a share of value for owner-occupied homes, from the Census American Community Survey. Several states tax rentals more than homes people live in, so a landlord’s rate is often at or above these.
Sources: Census Bureau and HUD, 2024 Rental Housing Finance Survey: single-unit rentals (infographic) (opens in a new tab); Tax Foundation, Facts & Figures 2026, Table 33: property tax as a share of home value, 2024 (opens in a new tab).
The tax law treats a rental building, but not its land, as wearing out. Each year you deduct a slice of what the building cost: 1/27.5 of it since 1987. That deduction can turn real cash profit into a loss on paper: on a $300,000 building (land not counted), about $10,909 a year. When you sell, the depreciation you took is taxed at up to 25%, usually more than the rate on the rest of the gain. And since 1986 most people can deduct rental losses against their pay only up to $25,000 a year, and only if their income is under $150,000. At $120,000 the limit is $15,000; losses above it wait until the rental makes a profit or you sell.
Years over which a rental building is written off, by when it was bought
40 years before 1971, as short as 15 years in the early 1980s, and 27.5 years since 1987.
Rental losses you can deduct against your pay, by income
Up to $25,000 a year, shrinking from $100,000 of income to nothing at $150,000. These limits are the 1986 ones; risen with prices they would run from about $294,000 to $441,000.
Tax returns reporting a rental loss, by income, 2023
33.5% of the 9.5 million returns with rental or royalty income showed a loss. Fewer did above $200,000, where the law holds most losses back.
A tax loss isn't the same as losing money
33.5% of returns with rental income showed a loss in 2023, many of them because of depreciation rather than cash. Fewer high earners report one: above $150,000 their losses are held back for later years. The limits have never risen with prices; the $100,000 of 1986 is about $294,000 today.
- Recovery periods follow IRS Publication 534 for property placed in service before 1987 (15 years before March 16, 1984; 18 years to May 8, 1985; 19 years to the end of 1986) and Publication 527 since (27.5 years, straight line, mid-month). Earlier periods are from a Congressional Research Service review; before 1971 owners could also take faster write-offs in early years.
- The 25% is a maximum rate on “unrecaptured section 1250 gain”, set in 1997; someone in a lower bracket pays their own rate on it.
- The $25,000 allowance is for owners who actively participate (approve tenants, set rents), and phases out at 50 cents per dollar of modified adjusted gross income above $100,000. A married couple filing separately who lived apart all year gets half, phasing out from $50,000 to $75,000; living together, none. Real estate professionals are treated differently, and a short-term rental with an average stay of seven days or less is not a rental activity under these rules at all. The 1986-to-2025 price rise is ×2.937, from annual consumer price averages.
- Loss shares are returns with a net rental-and-royalty loss divided by all returns with a net income or loss in that category, IRS Table 1.4, tax year 2023. Reading the drop above $200,000 as the passive-loss limit is our inference, not the IRS’s.
- On a sale, depreciation is taxed back on what you were allowed to take, even if you never claimed it. Higher earners also pay the 3.8% net investment income tax on the gain. A like-kind (1031) exchange into another rental puts the tax off; heirs who inherit the rental get a basis stepped up to its value, which clears both the gain and the depreciation to be taxed back. Since January 19, 2025, 100% bonus depreciation is back for parts of a building that a cost-segregation study separates out.
Sources: IRS Publication 527: Residential Rental Property (opens in a new tab); IRS Publication 534: depreciating property placed in service before 1987 (opens in a new tab); IRS Topic 409: capital gains and losses (the 25% rate on depreciation) (opens in a new tab); Internal Revenue Code §469: passive activity losses (1986) (opens in a new tab); IRS Statistics of Income, Publication 1304, Table 1.4: rental and royalty income and loss, tax year 2023 (opens in a new tab).
For the typical rented house with a mortgage, rent after running costs paid only 80% of the mortgage in 2023; two-to-four-unit buildings, 74%. The owners made up the rest each month, counting on the loan paying down and the house gaining value. That can work, but it means a rental needs spare cash every month, and it depends on prices rising. Many of those owners bought years ago at lower prices and rates; at today’s prices and a 7% mortgage the shortfall is usually bigger, as the example below shows. Bought with cash, or with a big down payment, the same house pays its way.
One month of a rental
You top it up by $1,445 a month: after running costs, rent covers 46% of the mortgage. It breaks even at about $4,022 rent.
- Rent$2,500
- Empty between tenants (5% of rent)−$125
- Property tax−$458
- Landlord insurance−$209
- Repairs and upkeep−$492
- Mortgage−$2,661
- You add each month$1,445
Rent is 0.5% of the price a month (the 1% rule asks for 1%). Of the mortgage, $328 this month pays down the loan: that part comes back to you as equity when you sell.
The calculator’s starting assumptions: property tax of 1.1% of the price a year (above the 0.85% national average for homes people live in, as landlords often pay more), insurance, a landlord-insurance extra, upkeep and yard costs scaled to the price, and a 30-year fixed mortgage. It leaves out tax, rent increases and the house’s gain in value, which the calculator adds over the years you hold it.
In the calculator: enter the price, rent, mortgage and costs, and the Investment Property calculator follows the rental year by year: rent rising, the loan paying down, the house gaining value, taxes with depreciation and the passive-loss limit, and what you’d have if you sold, compared with putting the same money in stocks. If you already own one, it weighs keeping it against selling. Try it with your numbers.
Try it with your own numbers
The Investment Property calculator shows what a rental is likely to earn over the years you hold it, against putting the same money into stocks, with the tax worked out.
Educational information, not tax or investment advice. Rules for rental income are detailed; a tax professional can tell you how they apply to you.




