Learn the history behind the numbers
Cars, explained
For most households a car is the second-biggest purchase after a home, and the one that loses value fastest. Here is how car prices have moved against everything else, how quickly each kind of car loses value, what a year of owning one really costs, and when buying beats leasing.
Plain words first, the method folded underneath, and a source under every number. Our Car Buy vs Lease calculator works out which costs you less for the car you are looking at. Last reviewed November 2026.

At a glance
US figures. Tap one for the history behind it.
- Average price paid for a new car, October 2026up 2.1% in a year; a compact car about $28,030$51,109
- Value an SUV loses each year, in our calculatorelectric cars 22% a year, trucks 11%12%
- Cost of owning a new car for a year, 2026about $1,072 a month, $4,422 of it lost value$12,863
- New cars financed with a lease, second quarter of 2026lease payments averaged $148 a month less than loans24%
- Buying instead of leasing, kept 6 years, our starting example$66 a month if kept 3 years, $279 a month if kept 10$152 a month less
How paying for a car works
There are three ways to get a car: pay cash, borrow and pay the loan off over a few years, or lease. A lease is a long rental: you pay for the value the car loses while you drive it, plus interest and fees, then hand it back. Loan payments are higher because they pay for the whole car, but they end and you keep what is left; lease payments are lower, but if you keep leasing you always have a payment. Whichever you choose, the biggest cost is usually not the payment but the value the car loses.
For thirty years cars were one of the few things that barely got dearer. From 1990 to 2020 prices in general rose 98% while new car prices, counted the way the government counts them (adjusting for better safety gear and features), rose 22%. Then the pandemic shut factories and a chip shortage cut supply: used car prices jumped 43% in two years, and new car prices are up 21% since 2020. In October 2026 buyers paid $51,109 on average for a new car; a compact car averaged about $28,030 and an electric car $56,220.
Car prices against everything else, 1990 to 2025 (1990 = 100)
Prices in general rose 146%; new cars only 47%, about half of it since 2020. Each line starts at 100 in 1990, so 150 means 50% higher.
Why the price index rose less than stickers
The average car is bigger and better equipped than in 1990, and buyers have moved from sedans to SUVs and trucks. The price index counts a car with airbags and a backup camera as partly a different product, so it shows what the same car costs; the average price paid shows what people actually spend, which rose faster. Used car prices, up 57% since 1990, have risen more than new ones because they follow new car supply.
Sources: Kelley Blue Book / Cox Automotive: average transaction price report, October 2026 (opens in a new tab); BLS consumer price index: new vehicles (CUUR0000SETA01), used cars and trucks (CUUR0000SETA02), all items (via FRED) (opens in a new tab).
The Car calculator takes the same share off what a car is worth each year, so the biggest drop in dollars comes first, when the car is worth the most. The yearly rate depends on the kind of car: sedans 15%, SUVs 12%, trucks 11%, luxury cars 20%, electric cars 22%. Many guides quote a bigger loss in the very first year, often about a fifth; the calculator spreads it evenly instead. Electric cars lose value fastest because batteries keep improving and the federal tax credits for new and used electric cars ended in September 2025, which pulled used prices down; trucks and SUVs hold value because demand for them stays strong. AAA puts the average new car’s loss at $4,422 a year over its first five years.
What a car is still worth, by kind, after each year
After five years a $40,000 truck is worth about $22,336; an EV, about $11,549.
Why the first owner pays the most
The day a new car is registered it becomes a used car, and buyers pay less for used. A two- or three-year-old car has already taken its steepest fall, often still has some warranty left, and costs a good deal less: the main reason a nearly new car is often the best value.
In the calculator: pick the kind of car, or set your own rate, and the Car calculator shows what it will be worth each year and what that means for buying against leasing. Try it with your numbers.
Sources: AAA: Your Driving Costs 2026 (September 2026) (opens in a new tab).
About one new car in four is leased. The lower payment is the attraction: on the calculator’s starting example, a $40,000 SUV, the lease costs $667 a month against $777 for a 60-month loan at 7.4%. But the payment is not the cost. Counting everything (payments, fees, insurance and upkeep, and what the car sells for at the end), buying costs $66 a month less if you keep the car three years, $152 over 6 and $279 over ten. The longer you keep a car, the more buying wins, because the loan ends and the car keeps working.
What driving costs a month, buying or leasing a $40,000 SUV, by years you keep at it
Buying costs $66 a month less than leasing if you keep the car 3 years, $152 if 6 and $279 if 10: a loan ends, while leasing again keeps the payment going.
When a lease makes sense
If you want a new car every three years whatever it costs, drive less than the lease allows, can deduct the car for a business, or want to avoid owning an electric car whose value may drop fast, a lease can be the right choice. Read the mileage limit (often 10,000 to 12,000 miles a year, with 20 to 25 cents for every mile over; unused miles are not refunded) and the fees at signing and return. Ask for the money factor, the lease’s interest rate in disguise: times 2,400 it is roughly the yearly rate.
- Each path’s net worth at the end: what the car is worth less any loan left, less every dollar paid out, plus what the cash one path keeps back would have earned. The difference from where you started, divided by the months, is the cost a month.
- Starting example: $40,000 SUV (sticker $42,000), 8% sales tax, a 60-month loan at 7.4% with $4,000 down, a 36-month lease with a 58% residual (what the leasing company expects the car to be worth at the end) and $2,000 at signing, 12,000 miles a year, $1,800 insurance and $600 upkeep a year (more after the warranty).
- Everything is in today’s dollars: each month’s cash is adjusted for inflation by its date.
In the calculator: enter the car, the loan and the lease offer you have, and the Car calculator shows which costs less for as long as you plan to keep it, and the year the answer flips if it does. Try it with your numbers.
Sources: Experian: State of the Automotive Finance Market, Q2 2026 (opens in a new tab).
AAA works out each year what a new car costs to run for its first five years. For 2026 the total is $12,863 a year, of which $4,422 is the value the car loses. In 2025, when AAA last broke the total down, insurance came to $1,694, loan interest $1,131, and fuel, upkeep, tires, registration and fees the rest. A loan payment covers the car itself; insurance, fuel and repairs come on top.
A year of owning a new car, 2025: where $11,577 goes
Losing value is the biggest cost, $4,334, more than 2 times the insurance.
Spend less on the car, not just the payment
A longer loan lowers the payment but adds interest and leaves you owing more than the car is worth for longer. Rules of thumb: put at least a fifth down, borrow for no more than four or five years, and keep all car costs under about a tenth of your income before tax (the common 20/4/10 rule). Keeping a reliable car a few years longer is the biggest saving most households have.
What a car loan’s interest rate costs, and paying debt down: Debt and interest rates, explained.
Sources: AAA: Your Driving Costs 2026 (September 2026) (opens in a new tab); AAA: Your Driving Costs 2025, cost breakdown (September 2025) (opens in a new tab).
Try it with your own numbers
The Car Buy vs Lease calculator takes the car, the loan and the lease you are offered, then shows what each really costs for as long as you keep it, counting what the car is worth at the end.
Educational information, not individual financial advice. Prices and rates vary by car, place and credit.




